Friday, 20 April 2007

Ray of hope?

Turkey and Pakistan, two influential Muslim states, have seen massive public demonstrations in recent days in which huge crowds protested that Islam was playing too big a role in public affairs. How about that! In Karachi, Pakistan's largest city, an estimated 100,000 people took to the streets Sunday to protest plans by an influential mosque to run a "Taliban-style" anti-vice campaign in the capital city of Islamabad. A day earlier, some 500,000 Turks staged a rally in Ankara urging Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, a former Islamist and head of the moderate (mmm..) Muslim ruling party, not to run for president, traditionally a secular and nonpartisan post.

The twin rallies come at a time of intense debate over the ability of moderate Muslims across the Islamic world to challenge more radical, anti-Western voices. "This weekend, for the first time in a long time, we've seen people power in action on the streets in Turkey," said Zeyno Baran, director of the Center for Eurasian Policy at the Hudson Institute and a specialist on Turkish politics. Moderates in Turkey, an overwhelmingly Muslim country, had been "fairly passive" in the past in defending the country's institutions from religious forces, Ms. Baran said.

They have relied on the country's staunchly secular military to defend the secular character of the country's laws and leading institutions. While a number of leading Muslim figures have spoken out against Islamist militants and jihadist terror networks like al Qaeda, an extensive new study by the Rand Corp. released last month found that extremists have dominated the public debate in recent years. They're really on the ball, those Rand guys.

"By and large, radicals ... have been successful in intimidating, marginalizing or silencing moderate Muslims -- those who share the key dimensions of democratic culture -- to varying degrees," a truly dramatic finding. The Rand authors stated that radical forces not only use violence to cow more-moderate rivals, but they generally are better funded and organized, often with links to extremist forces in other Islamic countries. "This asymmetry in resources and organization explains why radicals, a small minority in almost all Muslim countries, have influence disproportionate to their numbers," the authors stated.

Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf has tried to walk a fine line, backing the U.S.-led campaign to oust the fundamentalist Taliban regime in neighboring Afghanistan - now going down the tube, by the way - without cutting all ties to increasingly militant Islamic political forces at home. Sunday's rally, held in a southern political stronghold of the president, targeted a new campaign by a prominent mosque in Islamabad to set up a parallel court based on the Islamic Shariah legal code. Students from the mosque have been harassing owners of brothels and music shops in the capital.

Your Savant wishes the protestors well, needless to say. But equally, there's no such thing as a moderate Muslim. If he's moderate, and most of those professing to be Muslims are - then he's not following the orders of the "Prophet".

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

There are some good insights in Turkey on - given by an atheist turk called "The Crimson Turq". I believe he is planning on setting up a "Turkey Watch" sub-forum. Turkey is mostly secular- though of course it is currently being corroded by the Islamists (read true Muslims) It remains to be seen if it will end up as a theocracy.
Pakistan will collapse. I believe the CIA thinks it won't last longer than 15 years, and that there are plans to bring parts of it under control from Afghanistan.
Currently they seem to be caving in to further Salafi demands for Sharia, and are probably bringing in a bill for killing Apostates (to make it nice and legal). (Up until recently they have had to use the "Blasphemy" Law to kill Apostates - it is easier when they have a dedicated law). Just imagine soon the Jihadis will have nukes.